Snakes, Self-Recognition, and Sociality | Psychology Immediately

Since the Seventies, scientists have put a spread of species in entrance of mirrors and recorded their reactions. They nonetheless can’t agree upon what the outcomes imply.

The normal check of self-recognition includes portray a mark on an animal someplace seen solely in a mirror, equivalent to its brow. If the animal makes use of the mirror to analyze the mark on its physique, it suggests it is aware of the reflection is of itself and never another animal.

The debate is over what mirror self-recognition would possibly suggest about an animal’s cognitive skills. Some scientists have linked success on the mirror check to self-awareness, whereas others argue that it won’t require a posh sense of self in any respect.

The listing of animals which have handed the mirror check is small however complicated. Great apes are likely to go, and at the very least just a few individual dolphins and elephants appear to acknowledge their reflections. But along with these big-brained species, cleaner fish, roosters, and manta rays present some proof of mirror self-recognition.

One drawback with the mirror check is that it’s biased in direction of animals which can be primarily visible. Dogs, for example, fail the usual mirror check. But when offered with an olfactory self-recognition activity, they go (investigating their very own urine odor extra when it’s chemically “marked” with one other scent).

Scientists at Wilfrid Laurier University in Ontario, Canada, tailored this paradigm to check snakes, one other animal that interacts with the world primarily by way of olfaction. They report reverse ends in garter snakes and ball pythons, with implications for the ecology of self-recognition.

An Olfactory Mirror

The scientists examined two species of snakes with very completely different existence. Eastern garter snakes are lively, hunt bugs and fish, and combination with others of their type throughout mating season and for lengthy winter naps. Ball pythons, alternatively, are largely solitary and sedentary snakes that ambush their prey (primarily rodents).

But each snakes have oils of their skins that they go away on the bottom as they slither alongside. The scientists rubbed make-up removing pads alongside the underside of the snakes to gather their scents. Then, they examined the snakes individually by putting them in an extended, slim field containing pairs of scented pads.

Each snake was offered with completely different mixtures of 5 circumstances:

• The snake’s personal scent
• The snake’s personal scent with an olive oil “mark” added
• The olive oil mark by itself
• The scent of one other acquainted snake
• The scent of one other acquainted snake with olive oil added

The workforce measured the snakes’ curiosity by recording how a lot time they spent shut to every scent pad, in addition to by counting their tongue flicks.

“One nice thing about snakes is that they smell by flicking their tongues out,” says Noam Miller, head of the Collective Cognition Lab at Wilfrid Laurier University and one of many research’s authors. They carry out each lengthy and quick tongue flicks, with longer tongue flicks indicating extra curiosity in no matter they’re exploring.”

Miller and colleagues discovered that garter snakes carried out extra lengthy tongue flicks in response to their very own modified scent than to their very own scent with out an added mark. Garter snakes additionally investigated their very own modified scent greater than the olive oil alone or the marked scent of one other snake.

“These results suggest to us that garter snakes are able to recognize their own scent and tell when it has been changed somehow,” says Miller.

In distinction, ball pythons responded equally to all of the scented pads.

“These two snakes have very different ecologies, which will have shaped how their cognition and behavior works,” says Miller. “We don’t know if the pythons are unable to differentiate between these different odors or if they just aren’t motivated to investigate one more than the other.”

Snakes’ Sense of Self

According to Miller, two issues have been lacking from discussions of self-recognition assessments. The first is an understanding of the ecology of the species below research. In the case of those two snakes, the extra gregarious species (garter snakes) confirmed self-recognition, whereas the much less social species (ball pythons) didn’t. The means to differentiate oneself from others could also be tied to sociality. Or maybe self-recognition is simply simpler to look at in social species, who is perhaps extra motivated to work together with mirrors or scents.

Miller says the animal self-recognition literature additionally lacks a dialogue of the cognitive mechanisms that drive the habits.

“Once you have a positive result on a test of self-recognition, what does that mean?” he says. “There have been claims that passing self-recognition tests means that one is conscious or self-aware or has a concept of self. I think that may certainly be true for a lot of animals. But I don’t think that passing this test is strong evidence of that.”

The researchers say that there are numerous potential mechanisms, some pretty easy, that would allow an animal to go a self-recognition check. Explanations vary from merely realizing the distinction between self and not-self all the way in which as much as possessing self-awareness. Designing extra particular experiments to check these explanations might inform us extra about self-recognition than simply repeating the mirror check with completely different species. And with over 5,000 species of snakes on the market residing numerous existence, these reptiles supply alternatives to check which points of an animal’s ecology would possibly drive the evolution of self-recognition.

Miller admits that there are some “not great” stereotypes about reptiles, significantly snakes. “Even within the scientific community, there is a bias toward thinking that reptiles are slow, sluggish, and instinctive and that they are not cognitively sophisticated,” he says.

“A lot of my research, including this paper, is geared toward overcoming that bias because it is definitely not true.”

References