Loss of catalytic activity in the MYSM1
D660N mutant protein
To generate an allele encoding a catalytically inactive MYSM1 in mouse we chose to introduce the Mysm1D660N point mutation at the highly conserved aspartic acid 660 residue within the JAMM motif of the MPN catalytic domain (Fig. 1A). This residue is considered essential to the catalytic mechanism and is predicted to interact with both Zn2+ and the substrate3,4. To confirm that the catalytic activity of MYSM1D660N is indeed impaired, we expressed and purified both wild-type MYSM1 and MYSMD660N proteins from Sf9 insect cells, and performed an in vitro catalytic activity assay using Ubiquitin-Rhodamine 110 as substrate. The proteins were purified from Sf9 insect cells at a similar yield (0.78 mg/L of cells for wild type MYSM1, 0.83 mg/L of cells for MYSM1D660N) and eluted in a retention volume slightly lower than 13 mL in size exclusion chromatography, demonstrating that they were not aggregated and likely not misfolded (Fig. S1A). We found that wild-type MYSM1 cleaved the substrate in a dose-dependent manner with a Km of 8.5 μM for the substrate, whereas the activity of MYSMD660N was completely abrogated (Fig. 1B). This confirms that the D660N mutation inactivates the catalytic activity of mouse MYSM1 protein.
Generation of the Mysm1
D660N mouse strain
We used CRISPR/Cas9-mediated genome editing in zygotes to introduce the point mutation into exon 16 of Mysm1. C57BL/6 zygotes were co-injected with Cas9 protein and a gRNA, along with two homology-dependent recombination (HDR) templates. Since conventional knockout of MYSM1 causes partial embryonic lethality, we used two HDR templates to increase the efficiency of the procedure: one HDR template for the introduction of the D660N mutation and a second template introducing silent mutations to disrupt the gRNA recognition site24. The founder harboring both the D660N and silent mutations was backcrossed onto C57BL/6 mice to generate heterozygous Mysm1D660N mice lacking the silent mutations on the other Mysm1 allele. Sanger sequencing of the genomic DNA demonstrated successful introduction of the point mutation that translates into the MYSM1D660N amino acid substitution in the protein (Fig. 1C). The sequencing window covered 371 nucleotides (NCBI GRCm39 Mysm1, Gene ID: 320713, range from 94,840,309 to 94,840,679), and included the entire Mysm1 exon 16 and ≥ 80 nucleotides of the flanking introns at both ends. This demonstrated no other mutations apart from those shown in Fig. 1C and resulting in the D660N substitution in the protein. As the mutations are located > 20 nucleotides away from the 3′ splice site of Mysm1 exon-16 they are not expected to disrupt splicing25; and further analysis of the Mysm1D660N allele with the Spliceator online tool (www.lbgi.fr/spliceator/) predicted no changes in splicing. Furthermore, RT-qPCR analysis of mouse bone marrow cells with the primer pairs spanning Mysm1 exon junctions 15–16 and 16–17 demonstrated no changes in the levels of Mysm1 transcript successfully spliced across these exon junctions in Mysm1DN/DN compared to Mysm1+/+ control cells (Fig. S1B).
Mysm1
DN/DN mouse model: partial embryonic lethality and developmental phenotypes
Mysm1DN/DN mice were born in sub-Mendelian numbers, with only ~ 4% of offspring from an intercross of two heterozygous parents having the Mysm1DN/DN genotype, indicating that the loss of MYSM1 catalytic activity causes increased embryonic lethality (Fig. 1D). At adulthood, Mysm1DN/DN mice were significantly smaller in length and weight than their littermates (Fig. 1E,F), and had abnormally short tails (Fig. 1F), as previously seen in the Mysm1−/− mice8,9. Importantly, we demonstrated similar levels of MYSM1 protein in Mysm1DN/DN and control Mysm1+/+ bone marrow cells, and the expected loss of MYSM1 protein expression in Mysm1−/− cells (Fig. 1G). Overall, we highlight the similarity in the gross developmental phenotypes of the Mysm1DN/DN and Mysm1−/− mouse strains, and establish the essential role of the MYSM1 DUB catalytic activity in vivo.
Mysm1
fl/DNCreERT2 mouse model for an inducible loss of the MYSM1 catalytic activity
Given the partial embryonic lethality and low availability of the Mysm1DN/DN mice, we crossed the mice to the Mysm1fl/flCreERT2 mouse strain that allows highly efficient Mysm1fl to Mysm1Δ allele conversion with tamoxifen treatment, as demonstrated in our previous studies17,26. Here we derived cohorts of CreERT2-transgenic mice of Mysm1fl/+, Mysm1fl/fl, and Mysm1fl/DN genotypes, which were born in normal Mendelian numbers, lacked any obvious developmental phenotypes, and bred normally (data not shown). Following tamoxifen treatment, we demonstrated a strong depletion of MYSM1 protein in Mysm1Δ/Δ mouse splenocytes, but comparable retention of MYSM1 protein levels in Mysm1Δ/+ and Mysm1Δ/DN samples (Fig. 1H). The CreERT2 Mysm1fl/DN model will test the effects of the loss of MYSM1 DUB catalytic activity on the maintenance of hematopoiesis, leukocyte development, and other aspects of mammalian physiology, independently of its roles in mouse development and the significant developmental phenotypes seen in the Mysm1DN/DN mouse strain.
Severe hematologic dysfunction in Mysm1
DN/DN and Mysm1
fl/DNCreERT2 mice
Hematology analyses of the blood of Mysm1DN/DN and Mysm1−/− mice relative to the Mysm1+/+ controls, demonstrated severe hematopoietic dysfunction, characterized by macrocytic anemia, with reduction in blood erythrocyte counts, hematocrit, and hemoglobin concentration, as well as an increased in mean corpuscular volume (MCV, Fig. 2A). Severe depletion of leukocytes and lymphocytes in Mysm1DN/DN relative to control Mysm1+/+ mice was also observed (Fig. 2A). Overall, the reported anemia and leukopenia phenotypes of Mysm1DN/DN mice are highly consistent with those observed in the Mysm1−/− mouse model (Fig. 2A), and also clinically in the patients with MYSM1 loss-of-function mutations1,5,6,7.
We conducted further hematology analyses on tamoxifen-treated CreERT2 transgenic mice of Mysm1+/fl, Mysm1fl/fl, and Mysm1DN/fl genotypes, and observed highly similar hematopoietic phenotypes in the Mysm1Δ/DN mice, including macrocytic anemia, leukopenia, and lymphocyte depletion (Fig. 2B). We further observed an increase in platelets in Mysm1DN/Δ mice (Fig. 2B), while platelets were not quantified in the Mysm1DN/DN model due to increased clotting of the blood samples. Elevated platelet counts were previously reported for the Mysm1−/− mouse strain1,8, and although the mechanisms remain poorly understood they may be linked to elevated inflammatory response in Mysm1−/− mice14,15,16, as thrombocytosis is a common feature of systemic inflammation27. Overall, we demonstrate that the loss of MYSM1 DUB catalytic activity in either constitutive or inducible mouse models results in a severe hematologic dysfunction with highly similar phenotypes to the previously characterized Mysm1−/− and Mysm1Δ/Δ mouse strains.
Depletion of lymphoid and myeloid immune cells in the Mysm1
DN/DN mice
Severe reduction in lymphocyte numbers, including B cells, CD4 T cells, CD8 T cells, and NK cells, was also observed in the spleen of the Mysm1DN/DN and Mysm1Δ/DN mice, with the overall phenotype being highly similar to that of the Mysm1−/− and Mysm1Δ/Δ mouse models (Fig. 3A–D). An increase in the proportion of dead cells was also observed, particularly for splenic B cells and NK cells in Mysm1DN/DN relative to control Mysm1+/+ mice (Fig. S2A). Further analyses confirmed the depletion of splenic transitional (T1–3) and follicular B cells in the Mysm1DN/DN and Mysm1Δ/DN mice, with a somewhat milder depletion of the marginal zone B cell population (Fig. S3A–B). The numbers of myeloid cells, including monocytes, macrophages, and neutrophils, were somewhat more variable across the experimental groups, but also showed a depletion in the Mysm1DN/DN and Mysm1Δ/DN mice (Fig. 3E,F, Fig. S2B).
Severe depletion of lymphocyte precursors in the Mysm1
DN/DN mice
We further analyzed for the B and T cell precursor subsets in the bone marrow and thymus of Mysm1DN/DN and Mysm1−/− mice, relative to the Mysm1+/+ controls. We observed a strong depletion of most B cell precursor subsets, including pre-pro-B and pro-B cells (Fractions A-B), pre-B cells, and the immature and mature bone marrow B cell populations in the Mysm1DN/DN and Mysm1−/− mice (Fig. 4A,C). Similarly, we observed a strong depletion of most thymocyte populations in the Mysm1DN/DN and Mysm1−/− mice (Fig. 4B,D). Overall, this indicates that the loss of MYSM1 DUB catalytic activity or the loss of MYSM1 protein expression both result in a severe defect in B and T lymphocyte development.
Hematopoietic progenitor depletion and hematopoietic dysfunction in the Mysm1
DN/DN mice
To further characterize the dysfunction in hematopoiesis resulting from the in vivo loss of MYSM1 DUB catalytic activity, Mysm1DN/DN, Mysm1−/−, and control Mysm1+/+ mice were analyzed for the numbers of hematopoietic progenitor cells across the different lineages, as well as for the multipotent progenitors (MPPs) and hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs). We observed a significant depletion of common lymphoid (CLP), common myeloid (CMP), and granulocyte monocyte (GMP) progenitors in Mysm1DN/DN mice (Fig. 5A), while changes in megakaryocyte erythroid (MEP) and megakaryocyte (MkP) progenitors did not reach statistical significance (Fig. 5A). The numbers of HSC and MPP1-3 cells were highly variable between the Mysm1DN/DN mice, and showed trends for expansion, which however did not reach statistical significance (Fig. 5B,C), and this likely reflects the competing effects of the loss of HSC quiescence and increased cell apoptosis, as previously reported in the Mysm1−/− mouse models10,19. Importantly, there was a severe depletion of the lymphoid primed MPP4 cells in both Mysm1DN/DN and Mysm1−/− relative to control mice (Fig. 5B,C), further supporting the essential role of MYSM1 DUB catalytic activity for lymphopoiesis. Furthermore, an increase in the proportion of dead cells was observed particularly for lymphoid biased MPP4 and CLP cells in Mysm1DN/DN relative to control Mysm1+/+ mice (Fig. S2C-D).
The dysfunction in lymphopoiesis and erythropoiesis in the Mysm1DN/DN mice was further demonstrated with colony-forming units (CFU) assays, showing a severe depletion of B-cell lineage and erythroid lineage CFUs in the Mysm1DN/DN and Mysm1−/− relative to the control mice (Fig. 5D). No analysis of myeloid CFUs was conducted, as in previous studies myeloid CFU numbers in Mysm1−/− mice were not significantly impaired8.
Cell intrinsic role of MYSM1 DUB catalytic activity in hematopoiesis
To directly test the cell-intrinsic requirement for the MYSM1 DUB catalytic activity in hematopoiesis, competitive bone marrow chimeras were set up. CD45.1+ wild type bone marrow was mixed in a 1:1 ratio with the bone marrow of CD45.2+ CreERT2 mice of Mysm1+/fl, Mysm1fl/fl, or Mysm1DN/fl genotypes, and transplanted into three independent groups of lethally irradiated recipients (Fig. 6A). The recipient mice were bled at 12-weeks to confirm the normal reconstitution with donor bone marrow across the genotypes (data not shown), and subsequently all the mice were administered with tamoxifen to induce the Mysm1fl to Mysm1Δ allele conversion. The mice were analyzed for the relative contributions of the CD45.2+ bone marrow to the different hematopoietic lineage, across the three Mysm1 genotypes.
We observed a significant reduction in the contribution of the Mysm1DN/Δ donor hematopoiesis to the B cell, CD4 T cell, CD8 T cell, and NK cell populations in the mouse spleen (Fig. 6B), to monocyte and neutrophil populations in both spleen and bone marrow (Fig. 6B and not shown), and to all the leukocyte populations in the mouse blood (Fig. S4A). Similar defects in the reconstitution were observed for the Mysm1DN/Δ hematopoietic progenitor cells, including the lineage committed progenitors (CMPs, GMPs, CLPs, MEPs, and MkPs, Fig. 6C), all the developing B cell subsets (Fractions A-C, pre-B, and immature B cells, Fig. S4B), and the majority of T cell precursor subsets within the thymus (Fig. S4C). Among the multipotent HSC and MPP hematopoietic cells there was no defect in Mysm1DN/Δ reconstitution of the early HSC and MPP1-2 cells, likely reflecting the balancing effects of the loss of quiescence and increase in apoptosis among these cells, as in the Mysm1−/− mouse models10,19, however impaired reconstitution was seen for the latter myeloid-biased MPP3 and lymphoid-biased MPP4 subsets (Fig. S4D). Importantly, throughout the datasets presented above the Mysm1DN/Δ phenotypes aligned very well with the Mysm1Δ/Δ group, both showing strong impairment of hematopoietic function relative to the Mysm1+/Δ control (Fig. 6, S4). Overall, this demonstrates the essential and cell-intrinsic role of the MYSM1 DUB catalytic activity in the regulation of hematopoiesis, and suggests lack of significant MYSM1 mechanisms of action that are independent of its catalytic function.