A brand new examine raises the alarm
Climate change is...
-- Advertisment --
- Advertisement -
By Bridie Pearson-jones For Mailonline
14:48 23 Jan 2024, up to date 07:40 24 Jan 2024
Share or touch upon this text:
A glamorous entrepreneur who turned the primary person to obtain six gives on Dragons’ Den has been accused of ‘promoting snake oil’ and preying on the ‘most vulnerable and horribly in poor health individuals in society’.
Giselle Boxer, 31, from Sheffield, appeared on the BBC present final week and requested for £50,000 for a ten per cent stake in her business, Acu Seeds.
The mom of 1 mentioned she arrange the business, which sells £30 gold plated ear seeds, whereas on maternity depart, after she used an analogous product to ‘remedy herself from ME’.
She obtained the provide for the complete quantity from 5 of the dragons however settled on a smaller provide – £50,000 for 12.5 per cent of the business – from Steven Bartlett, 31, as a result of she is ‘non secular’ and ‘was advised she was going to fulfill an vital man known as Steven’.
But now varied docs and myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME) victims have hit out on the BBC and the business for selling an alternate medication with no scientific proof it will possibly assist ME or fatigue.
Both Ms Boxer and Mr Bartlett have been contacted for remark.
Giselle Boxer, 31, from Sheffield, appeared on the BBC present this week and requested for £50,000 for a ten per cent stake in her business, Acu Seeds
On the present, Deborah Meaden tried out the approach earlier than making a proposal
The ME affiliation has reported Acu Seeds to the Advertising Standards Agency and written to the BBC and chairman of the Commons tradition, media and sport committee and chairman of the well being and social care committee.
‘People who’ve ME/CFS are sometimes on very low incomes and within the absence of any efficient medical therapy are very vulnerable to those kind of unsubstantiated therapeutic claims.
‘They are fed up with the way in which by which unproven and costly therapies are recurrently being promoted to them.
‘This programme has due to this fact triggered an excessive amount of upset and anger within the ME/CFS [Chronic Fatigue Syndrome] affected person neighborhood,’ the letter reads.
It provides that in Dragons’ Den not one of the panel requested any questions on ‘validity Acu Seeds in ME/CFS and whether or not there was any scientific proof of security and efficacy for this product’.
Dr Charles Shepard, Hon Medical Advisor for The ME Association, mentioned: ‘The means by which Dragons’ Den has been used to advertise an unproven therapy for ME/CFS has, not surprisingly, triggered an excessive amount of upset and concern within the ME affected person neighborhood.
‘People with ME/CFS are fed up with the way in which by which merchandise like this are recurrently being promoted when there isn’t a sound proof from correct placebo-controlled scientific trials to substantiate that they’re secure and efficient.
‘These kind of costly business merchandise and units shouldn’t be promoted to very vulnerable sick individuals till they’ve been correctly assessed for security and efficacy in scientific trials – in precisely the identical means that drug therapies are.’
The new business companions embraced earlier than Giselle mentioned working with Steven was a ‘full dream come true’Giselle usually takes to Instagram to share how she was ‘cured’ from Chronic Fatigue Syndrome
What is ME?
Myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME) is a long-term situation that causes excessive fatigue, sleeping difficulties and mind fog.
It is believed to have an effect on 250,000 Brits and round 17million worldwide.
Symptoms are linked to the physique and mind’s lack of ability to get well after expending even small quantities of power.
Not everybody experiences the identical signs and the way lengthy they final can differ from months to years.
Some discover that they do not return utterly to the way in which they felt earlier than they turned in poor health.
Anyone will be affected nevertheless it’s extra frequent in girls and tends to develop between the mid-20s and mid-40s.
There isn’t a particular check for ME, so it is identified primarily based on signs and by ruling out different situations.
Treatment goals to alleviate the signs and contains remedy, power administration and medicine.
The explanation for ME isn’t recognized however it’s regarded as triggered by an an infection, issues with the immune system or a hormone imbalance.
ME victims have taken to social media to complain in regards to the product and accused Giselle of promoting ‘snake oil’Giselle usually posts on Instagram about her well being journey, nevertheless it has since come into query
How do the ear seeds work?
Ear seeds can work as tiny acupressure units to assist with ache, insomnia and anxiousness.
Acupuncturists historically use vaccaria seeds, which come from the flowering herb.
Users are normally inspired to therapeutic massage the seeds two or thrice a day.
This sort of auriculotherapy supposedly releases pure endorphins.
According to Acu Seeds, their ear seeds have been impressed by Chinese medication.
The model’s ear seeds – that are plated with gold or silver – have an adhesive sticker
The web site reads: ‘Think of it like reflexology, however for the ears as an alternative of toes.
‘They additionally create continuous, light stress on nerve impulses within the ear which ship messages to the mind that sure organs or programs want assist.
‘The mind will then ship indicators and chemical compounds to the remainder of the physique to assist no matter illnesses you’re experiencing, releasing endorphins into the bloodstream, stress-free the nervous system, and naturally soothing ache and discomfort.’
And he is not the one physician pushing again in opposition to the product.
Dr. Edzard Ernst, an MD and PhD who specialising in analysis round various medicines mentioned there may be ‘no good proof’ to assist any of her claims.
‘There isn’t any sound proof that these acupressure units are efficient for ME or different situations.
‘To give severely struggling sufferers false hope is unethical; to take money from it’s despicable, in my opinion.
‘I’m upset that the BBC makes use of a light-weight leisure programme for deceptive gullible shoppers and determined sufferers. I hope in future the BBC may do a minimal of analysis earlier than broadcasting overt medical nonsense,’ he advised FEMAIL.
Other individuals who endure from ME and persistent fatigue syndrome have taken to social media to complain.
One TikToker, known as Rebecca, who shares movies about her ME mentioned: ‘As if it is not unhealthy sufficient she’s bragging about shopping for them for £3 and promoting them for £30, along with her gigantic gross and web margins, effectively it seems she’s additionally promoting individuals in her membership snake oil’.
Another, Ollie Benson, who has ME, likened the Dragons’ funding to ‘scamming most cancers sufferers’ and branded the business ‘extremely unethical’.
‘The BBC has backed, endorsed and marketed this business to thousands and thousands of individuals worldwide’.
Ollie says ME turned him from a aggressive swimmer and water polo participant to somebody who may ‘barely walk up the steps’
‘Gisele, and now Steven Bartlett are preying on a number of the most vulnerable, horribly in poor health individuals in society, deceptive them, mendacity to them and making the most of their sheer desperation, all for their very own monetary acquire.
Others have taken to X and Facebook to complain saying the Dragons are after a ‘fast money seize’.
Steven Bartlett shared a clip from the present on LinkedInGiselle usually shares snaps of her making an attempt acupuncture
A BBC spokesperson mentioned: ‘Dragons’ Den options merchandise from entrepreneurs and isn’t an endorsement of them.
‘Dragons’ Den reveals actual businesses pitching to buyers to carry the lid on what occurs within the business world. This episode options an entrepreneur sharing their very own, private expertise that led to a business creation.’
In the episode, Giselle mentioned she went type being an promoting govt with a busy social life to unable to depart the home.
She says she was identified with ME and advised by docs she would by no means get well or be capable of have youngsters.
Myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME) causes excessive tiredness, sleeping issues and mind fog, in lower than 12 months with the assistance of acupuncture and Chinese ear seeds.
Viewers have taken to social media to say they’re ‘disgusted’ on the present
ME Association’s letter to the BBC
On Thursday January 18th the Dragons Den programme included a presentation from an entrépeneur who has arrange a business that’s promoting a medical product known as Acu Seeds.
This product, which prices £3 to provide and is offered for £30, is clearly being aimed a individuals who have ME/CFS and plenty of different particular medical situations – these are situations are listed on the Acu Seeds web site and Facebook web page.
The panel interviews failed to incorporate any questions on whether or not there was any validity to the scientific foundation for the usage of Acu Seeds in ME/CFS and whether or not there was any scientific proof of security and efficacy for this product in relation to any of the medical situations that it’s aimed toward.
Academic evaluation of the pseudoscience behind Acu Seeds.
The Advertising Standards Authority have very strict tips on the promoting of medicinal merchandise and make it clear that therapeutic claims can’t be made except they’re supported by strong proof of security and efficacy from placebo managed scientific trials.
No such scientific trials have been carried out in relation to Acu Seeds and I’ve due to this fact referred the therapeutic claims of their promotional materials to the ASA.
The Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Authority even have very clear laws garding the promotion of medical units resembling this.
People who’ve ME/CFS are sometimes on very low incomes and within the absence of any efficient medical therapy are very vulnerable to those kind of unsubstantiated therapeutic claims.
They are fed up with the way in which by which unproven and costly therapies are recurrently being promoted to them.
This programme has due to this fact triggered an excessive amount of upset and anger within the ME/CFS affected person neighborhood.
I might add that my issues about the way in which in why this programme seems to have made with none correct background checks earlier than getting used to advertise Acu Seeds are additionally shared by Professor Edzard Ernst.
There seems to have been a severe error of judgement in the way in which by which Dragons Den failed to hold out the required background checks on the ethics of this product and went forward to offer what was mainly an uncritical promotion of an unproven medical product.
These issues have additionally been handed to the All Party Parliamentary Group on ME at Westminster.
Yours sincerely
Dr Charles Shepherd
Hon Medical Adviser ME Association
Giselle then turned pregnant. There isn’t any proof that ME reduces fertility charges however some associated illnesses — resembling irregular intervals and endometriosis — could make it more durable to conceive.
She gave up her profession in promoting to turn out to be a stay-at-home mom. While on maternity depart, she determined to launch her personal ear seed business.
She spent 18 months building her business utilizing simply £5,000 of her personal financial savings and managed to make a wholesome revenue her first yr.
The mom of a three-year-old daughter then made Dragons’ Den historical past as she turned the primary contestant to get a proposal from all six judges.
In her pitch, she mentioned: ‘My business is the best mixture of magnificence and wellness. Today, I’m asking for £50,000 funding for 10 per cent of my business.
‘Four years in the past I used to be identified with ME. I went from working in a prime promoting company with a busy social life and exercising recurrently to being largely housebound and being unable to walk greater than 5 minutes with out having to get again into mattress.
‘I used to be advised by docs that I might by no means get well, work once more or have youngsters. I went on a private therapeutic journey utilizing food regimen, acupuncture, Chinese herbs and ear seeds.
‘Using this mix, I consider, helped me get well in lower than 12 months.
‘Soon after, I felt pregnant and it was whereas on maternity depart that I setup Acu Seeds after realising there was a spot available in the market for ear seed kits for individuals to make use of at home’.
Giselle usually shares images to Instagram exhibiting her journey from ‘ME’ to wellnessThe entrepreneur made historical past – however her ethics have been known as into query
Action of ME’s letter to the Chair of the Culture, Media and Sport Committee and Chair of the Health and Social Care Committee
Dear Dame Caroline and Mr Brine,
We are writing to you in your capability as Chair of the Culture, Media and Sport Committee and Chair of the Health and Social Care Committee respectively, on behalf of the M.E. neighborhood, in mild of an episode of the BBC’s Dragon’s Den which aired on 18 January 2024.
The episode in query featured an entrepreneur who was looking for funding in her ‘acu seed’ business. Giselle Boxer advised the Dragons that she had been identified with Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (M.E.) and that utilizing this product alongside a mix of different medicines ‘aided’ her restoration inside 12 months.
We are very involved that the way in which by which her pitch was introduced on Dragons Den means that this product was answerable for her restoration and may due to this fact be thought of an efficient therapy.
Sadly, there may be at present no recognized efficient therapy for M.E. There has been a definite paucity of analysis into this illness, in comparison with different long-term situations, which implies that M.E. remains to be and not using a remedy.
As a consequence, we remind individuals to solely take medical recommendation from appropriately certified healthcare professionals and to make sure that any therapy choices are evidence-based and absolutely knowledgeable.
As chances are you’ll bear in mind, Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (M.E.) is a long-term fluctuating sickness that causes signs affecting many physique programs, mostly the nervous and immune programs.
Symptoms of M.E. embrace debilitating ache, excessive sensitivity to noise and light-weight, and protracted fatigue related to post-exertional malaise; the physique and mind’s lack of ability to get well after expending even small quantities of power.
M.E. isn’t a brand new situation and while some individuals make good progress and should get well, many in our neighborhood will expertise these signs for many years, with essentially the most severely affected (round 1 in 4 individuals with M.E.) usually unable to depart their home or mattress.
According to the business’s web site, acu seeds are ‘a needle-free type of auriculotherapy which have been utilized in Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) for hundreds of years.’
The web site claims the product ‘might assist a broad spectrum of well being issues together with anxiousness, stress, complications, digestion, immunity, and focus.’
In her TV look, Giselle doesn’t explicitly say that acu seeds cured her sickness and while the web site was up to date the day after the episode’s airing and now doesn’t declare that acu seeds will remedy M.E. or different diseases, it beforehand said that ‘by way of the usage of acupuncture, Chinese herbs and ear seeds, Giselle is now absolutely recovered (from ME) and thriving!’.
It is vital that broadcasters make each effort to make sure that content material is correct and doesn’t comprise deceptive and doubtlessly harmful info. Given the episode in query was aired throughout prime time on BBC One, we fear {that a} bigger viewers can have heard this pitch which quantities to an unfounded declare that this type of various medication can remedy M.E.
Additional issues have been raised in relation to a weblog publish, promoted on a authorities web site on 18 January, which particulars Giselle’s look on the Dragons Den and contains a heading ‘Seeds that heal’.
In the age of social media and disinformation, we are inclined to belief main broadcasters just like the BBC and .gov.uk websites to offer us with factual and dependable content material. In this case, we consider they’ve fallen in need of these expectations.
This speaks to a bigger downside in our society. The web gives an infinite variety of sources at our fingertips, however we face difficulties making an attempt to average these.
People can access info from untrustworthy and doubtlessly unsafe sources which might have severe penalties.
We know that the very first thing somebody does when they’re unwell or have a ache is search their signs on-line the place hundreds of search outcomes await them. Similarly, social media has turn out to be an more and more frequent supply of well being info with restricted moderation.
This episode of Dragons Den demonstrates how deceptive info could make its technique to even essentially the most trusted types of media. We really feel it is necessary, in your roles as Chairs of the Culture, Media and Sport Committee and the Health and Social Care Committee respectively, to research the position of media in selling unfounded well being claims and the influence this has on our well being and security.
We can be delighted to fulfill with you to debate this matter additional and stay up for listening to from you.
Yours sincerely,
Action for M.E.
Physios for ME
Dr Charles Shepherd, Hon Medical Advisor, The ME Association
Denise Howorth Kiklees and Calderdale Independent ME Support Group
(KCIMSEG)
Long Covid Support
ME Local Network (MELN)
Mark Harper, Chair, Cambridge ME Support Group
Susan Jones, Coordinator, Cambridgeshire Rural ME Support Group (CrMEtea)
Denise Spreag, #MEAction UK
Janet Sylvester, #MEAction Scotland
25% ME GROUP
Tymes Trust
Baroness Scott of Needham Market
Ear seeds have been invented by Dr. Paul Nogier within the Nineteen Fifties and are just like an historic Chinese medication device, which makes use of the rules of acuprssure however with out the needles.
Giselle mentioned: ‘They are tiny beads that stick onto the ear making use of stress on to nerve endings.
‘They ship indicators to the mind and physique to loosen up the nervous system, launch endorphins and naturally relieve ache.
‘I work on this business for 3 days per week and spend the remainder of my time working with my three-year-old daughter.’
During the pitch, Giselle put an ear seed on Deborah Meaden’s that are to be left on for 5 days.
Giselle advised the dragons that the ear seeds she was utilizing in her battle with persistent sickness weren’t ‘very lovely’ and have been ’embarrassing’ to have in your ear. This impressed her to design her personal extra discreet ear seeds.
She has been operating the business for 18 months and generated £92,000 in income in her first yr and a wholesome £64,000 web revenue – which the dragons discovered very spectacular.
She spent £5,000 of her personal financial savings to get the business off the bottom and took a £31,000 wage – and nonetheless managed a wholesome web revenue.
Sara Davies mentioned: ‘Honestly, I’ve nothing to fault you on. That is all shaping up very well to date.’
Asked about her imaginative and prescient for the model, Giselle mentioned she desires it to be ‘as large as it will possibly probably be’.
She mentioned: ‘When I acquired pregnant, I assumed I needed to be a stay-at-home mum as a result of I had been working in advertising and marketing which I did not have a lot ardour with.’
But she has discovered she could be very obsessed with her business.
Gary Neville mentioned he could not go home if he did not make investments as his mom, sister, spouse and two ladies would ‘by no means forgive’ him. He supplied her all of the money – £50,000 for 10 per cent of the corporate.
Deborah Meaden mentioned she ‘it will almost be impolite’ to not provide her all of the money for 10 per cent of the business
Sara Davies, who has used ear seeds earlier than, was very impressed with Giselle’s business
Gary Neville mentioned he could not go home if he did not make investments as his mom, sister, spouse and two ladies would ‘by no means forgive me’
All the opposite judges supplied Giselle what she was asking for – other than Diary of a CEO host Steven Bartlett who supplied her £50,000 for 15 per cent
After his prolonged soccer profession, Gary has turned his consideration to building a business empire
Deborah Meaden mentioned she ‘it will almost be impolite’ to not provide her all of the money for 10 per cent of the business.
All the opposite judges supplied Giselle what she was asking for – other than Diary of a CEO host Steven Bartlett who supplied her £50,000 for 15 per cent.
He mentioned she was ‘un-uninvestable’ and made the case that he was ‘the dragon to tackle the business’.
He supplied her the money she needed for an even bigger stake within the business – 15 per cent.
To which, Peter Jones quipped, ‘oh, you don’t need it then’ whereas Gary Neville mentioned: ‘He’s not a dragon, he is a snake’.
Steven calmly responded: ‘You can see from the response of those two… it says one thing does not it.
‘I’ll depart it at that as a result of I do know what I can do for this business.’
It is the primary time in Dragons’ Den historical past that each one the judges made a proposal to speculate.
‘I do not know in case you consider in spirituality and all these items however I used to be advised I used to be going to fulfill a person known as Steven and that he was going to be actually vital.
‘This was earlier than any of this occurred. So, I would like to work with you [Steven].
She requested if he can be ‘versatile’ on his 15 per cent provide and requested if he may do 12.5 per cent — which he accepted.
The new business companions embraced earlier than Giselle mentioned partnering with Steven was a ‘full dream come true’.
Giselle mentioned: ‘I really feel like I wish to cry. I simply wish to make my daughter proud’.
About the editor
Hey there! I'm proud to be the editor of Pet News 2Day. With a lifetime of experience and a genuine love for animals, I bring a wealth of knowledge and passion to my role.
Experience and Expertise
Animals have always been a central part of my life. I'm not only the owner of a top-notch dog grooming business in, but I also have a diverse and happy family of my own. We have five adorable dogs, six charming cats, a wise old tortoise, four adorable guinea pigs, two bouncy rabbits, and even a lively flock of chickens. Needless to say, my home is a haven for animal love!
Credibility
What sets me apart as a credible editor is my hands-on experience and dedication. Through running my grooming business, I've developed a deep understanding of various dog breeds and their needs. I take pride in delivering exceptional grooming services and ensuring each furry client feels comfortable and cared for.
Commitment to Animal Welfare
But my passion extends beyond my business. Fostering dogs until they find their forever homes is something I'm truly committed to. It's an incredibly rewarding experience, knowing that I'm making a difference in their lives. Additionally, I've volunteered at animal rescue centers across the globe, helping animals in need and gaining a global perspective on animal welfare.
Trusted Source
I believe that my diverse experiences, from running a successful grooming business to fostering and volunteering, make me a credible editor in the field of pet journalism. I strive to provide accurate and informative content, sharing insights into pet ownership, behavior, and care. My genuine love for animals drives me to be a trusted source for pet-related information, and I'm honored to share my knowledge and passion with readers like you.
