Male implicated of beating puppy to death gets in innocent plea. Defense to subpoena housemates

A Naples guy implicated of beating his puppy to death has 2 organized court hearings in early December after he went into an innocent plea.

Investigators with the Collier County Constable’s Workplace Animal Ruthlessness Investigations Alliance apprehended Robert “Bobby” William Garon, 23, Aug. 11 and charged him with the late July slaying of his 5-month-old puppy.

Robert Garon is implicated of beating his puppy, Buzz Lightyear, to death.

His household spoke out: Naples guy implicated of beating puppy to death gets in innocent plea; household claims innocence

Missing out on puppy: CCSO looks for help in finding missing out on puppy one week after owners report disappearance

He bonded out Aug. 12 and officially went into an innocent plea Nov. 14, records show.

Through their lawyer Donald Day, from Naples-based Law Workplace of Donald D. Day, on Monday, the household subpoenaed Tradition Apartments, in the 7500 block of Campania Method, in Naples, court records show.

They’re requesting for copies of records associating with the apartment or condo where Robert Garon lived, in addition to for upkeep records beginning July 29, consisting of names and addresses of those who dealt with the residential or commercial property on that date.

Day stated the factor for the subpoena is that authorities declined to track them down and question them.

Robert Garon has 2 status hearings slated Dec. 5 and Dec. 8– the very first a movement to enable travel and contact with the household’s family pet, followed by a movement to subpoena the asked for records.

On the other hand, Day discussed the state submitted a movement for Garon’s veterinary records, however those aren’t yet at last hearing, which he stated ought to take place quickly.

Almost one month after Garon’s arrest, his household declared his innocence.

” It has actually been a moms and dad’s worst headache,” Suzanne Garon, Garon’s mom, informed the Daily News. “It’s been horrendous for our whole household. We have actually all gotten various hazards of violence and abuse.”

Suzanne Garon stated the household reported those hazards versus them to the Collier County Constable’s Workplace.

Story continues

Michelle Batten, representative for the Collier County Constable’s Workplace, validated they were examining a risk report in connection to the animal ruthlessness case.

” Individuals are stating definitely terrible things and not almost our kid, however to extended relative, our instant household and to extended relative who reside in other parts of the nation,” Suzanne Garon stated.

Robert Garon and his sweetheart lost their tasks following the puppy’s death.

Household, good friends’ side of the story

Suzanne Garon stated when Garon left his apartment or condo the night of July 29, his dog Buzz was completely great.

” He left and when he got back a number of hours later on, his roomie and his roomie’s pal, the 2 that really offered their declarations to the cops, together with 2 extra individuals, remained in the apartment or condo,” Suzanne Garon stated.

Bobby stated they were all drinking. And when he entered to go look at his puppy, Buzz remained in extreme distress. Bobby didn’t understand what occurred.

Suzanne Garon stated his sweetheart then got to your house and they hurried the puppy to the animal medical facility.

” They had no concept what occurred as I stated,” Suzanne Garon stated. “Bobby was not house.”

Jennifer Keller, a signed up nurse at Physicians Regional Health Care System in Naples and among Garon’s next door next-door neighbors, stated she could not think Robert Garon would do something harsh to his puppy.

” Bobby has actually been absolutely nothing however an accountable kid,” Keller stated. “He has actually been working extremely difficult and acquiring accreditations in his task.”

She’s understood the household for four-and-a-half years, she stated.

” I have actually never ever when seen Bobby be violent,” Keller stated. “I see him playing golf on the golf course … He never ever had any problems in concerns to getting upset with … If he’s not playing well. He acts much better than many grownups.”

What occurred July 29?

The constable’s workplace started examining Aug. 2 after Collier County Domestic Animal Solutions called them about a thought case of abuse including the puppy.

The examination revealed Garon and his sweetheart brought the hurt puppy to the Emergency situation Family Pet Health Center, in the 6500 block of Dudley Drive, on July 29.

The couple was not able to supply medical facility staff with a description for the puppy’s injuries, authorities stated.

The puppy was damp, disoriented, and not able to breathe typically, not able to stand or select its direct.

A vet evaluation exposed possible head injury, bruising to the best ear and mouth, and muscle damage throughout the body.

The puppy passed away at the medical facility from its injuries.

A witness later on got in touch with the medical facility and informed staff they heard Garon beating the puppy on July 29.

Healthcare facility staff called authorities.

Throughout the CCSO examination, vets carried out a necropsy on the puppy at Humane Society Naples.

The necropsy report consisted of the following, according to the post: “This dog’s death was triggered by non-accidental, blunt force injury to the head and body with secondary internal hemorrhage. I think he suffered considerably from his injuries prior to death.”

Robert Garon’s household asked for a polygraph through Naples-based John Hisler & & Associates– a Naples-based business focusing on polygraph screening.

The business stated in a news release the polygraph returned unfavorable, indicating it didn’t reveal that Garon hurt the puppy.

John Hisler, who administered the test, decreased to comment at the time in Robert Garon’s case and referred concerns to Day.

When asked if her kid is offered for remark, Suzanne Garon stated counsel encouraged it’s finest for Robert Garon to not react to media demands.

Tomas Rodriguez is a Breaking/Live News Press Reporter for the Naples Daily News and The News-Press. You can reach Tomas at [email protected] or 772-333-5501. Get in touch with him on Twitter @TomasFRoBeltran, Instagram @tomasfrobeltran and Facebook @tomasrodrigueznews.

This post initially appeared on Naples Daily News: Defense to subpoena housemates in Naples animal ruthlessness case