Every week, Dear Prudence solutions further questions from readers, only for Slate Plus members. Submit questions here. (It’s nameless!)
Dear Prudence,
In 2020, I, like many others, adopted my first canine, a golden retriever named Barely. It was love at first sight, and it’s been a joyful three years. However, three months in the past, we realized that she has a twin sister, Millet, who lives about 50 miles away. Since then, Barley and Millet have met at a canine park 5 occasions. Each time, they each appear elated to be collectively and don’t go away one another’s sides. Each time we go away, Barley whimpers for the remainder of the day. Now I really feel horrible that Barely and Millet had been offered off to 2 totally different households. It appears inhumane.
I just lately talked with Millet’s homeowners, and so they have been searching for a second canine and are prepared to undertake Barely. Is giving up for adoption the morally right factor to do? Please assist.
—Questioning Dog Owner
Dear Dog Owner,
I learn your letter and began Googling “Do dogs miss their siblings?” and landed on some almost-certainly-not-fact-checked info that they do, however just for two years. I’m fairly certain nobody has really requested a canine about this! Then my thoughts went to the deeper situation of whether or not it’s morally right to personal a canine in any respect. Maybe they miss their mothers. Maybe they miss their dads. Maybe they don’t even like individuals. Who is aware of?? This wasn’t actually a productive train.
So let me pull again from veterinary and philosophical inquiries which can be past the scope of this column. I hear in your letter that your instincts, your deep care to your pet, and your personal ethical compass are saying that Barley is struggling. You’ve even gone as far as to speak to Millet’s homeowners. This tells me that, no matter whether or not you’re right about Barley’s emotional state, one thing inside you is telling you loud and clear that he’d be higher off together with his sibling. Whether you’re proper or improper, feeling like chances are you’ll be inhumane to a helpless creature isn’t any solution to reside, and isn’t what having a canine is meant to be about. Barely could or is probably not completely happy. You positively aren’t. Pack up his toys and drop him off at Millet’s home. And then, once you’re prepared, take into consideration getting one other pup—solely this time, possibly don’t danger shaking the household tree? Try adopting from a shelter so that you’ll really feel extra assured that you’re enhancing your pet’s life relatively than holding them from their beloved ones.
More Advice From Slate
I’ve been low-contact with my abusive dad for a number of years now, and my psychological well being has drastically improved in consequence. I’m a queer trans person (they/them) and could be happiest by no means talking to him once more. I’m involved with my mom, who often offers me updates on his life. I do know my mom was victimized by him in her personal proper, however she additionally enabled and justified his abuse of me and my siblings. Now my mom is presently dying of a persistent sickness, and her prognosis is simply one other 12 months or two. I reside throughout the nation, though I plan to maneuver to be nearer to her this fall. But I’m already enthusiastic about her funeral: I don’t wish to go when it lastly occurs.
