This is Science Fictions with Stuart Ritchie, a subscriber-only e-newsletter from i. If you’d prefer to get this direct to your inbox, each single week, you may join right here.
Here’s a query I guess you’ve by no means thought of earlier than: does proudly owning a cat enhance your threat of getting schizophrenia? To be sincere, I’d by no means thought of it both, till this week when a new study appeared that attempted to reply precisely that query.
What’s the mechanism? That is, why would proudly owning a cat result in you creating signs of psychosis? The reply, some scientists suggest, is through toxoplasmosis. Cats are recognized to be a number for Toxoplasma gondii, the microscopic parasite. Experiments have found that rats, when contaminated with T. gondii, act in riskier methods – ways in which make them extra prone to be eaten by a cat, thus serving to the parasite unfold and reproduce.
Humans affected by acute toxoplasmosis – the illness that’s linked to T. gondii an infection – would possibly simply have some delicate bodily signs, or no signs in any respect. But these with weaker immune programs would possibly get one thing extra critical: in some cases, they will endure neurological signs corresponding to hallucinations and delusions.
And that’s the primary trace that bought scientists : the signs of schizophrenia and of toxoplasmosis can each contain hallucinations and delusions. Could there be a hyperlink? Certainly, some previous reviews of the scientific literature have discovered that these with schizophrenia usually tend to be contaminated with T. gondii than the typical person.
Then we simply want a few different hyperlinks within the chain. Does having a pet cat enhance your threat of a T. gondii an infection? It does indeed. And then: does having a pet cat enhance your threat of schizophrenia?
That’s what the new study supposed to search out out.
Paws for thought (dysfunction)
Something to keep in mind earlier than we begin, which could make the thought roughly scary relying in your scenario: that is about publicity to cats in formative years. Schizophrenia tends to be recognized within the early 20s; within the new assessment examine, the researchers solely checked out circumstances the place the cat publicity occurred earlier than the age of 25.
Looking by way of all of the research on the query of cats and schizophrenia, they discovered 17 that match the invoice: they needed to have some sort of measure of schizophrenia and a few measure of early-life cat publicity. These weren’t experiments, after all: it’s not like they gave some individuals a cat after which checked their psychological well being years later in comparison with a cat-free management group. They tended to be case-control research, the place individuals with the illness have been in comparison with related individuals with out.
Overall, the outcome was fairly clear: cat possession was correlated with a better threat of schizophrenia. People who had publicity to cats early in life had simply over twice the danger of the dysfunction, which is a fairly substantial hyperlink.
In the preliminary evaluation, it seemed as if one outlier examine, which discovered that cat house owners have been at an enormous 16 occasions the danger, was maybe driving the outcome: if every thing was down to only this one examine, the general outcome wouldn’t have been as dependable. But in one other evaluation, which managed for many elements like age, intercourse, training and so forth – and which not had such an excessive outlier – the outcome was mainly the identical: cats have been linked to twice the danger of schizophrenia.
Is that it, then? Does this reply our query and lead us to consider that cats trigger schizophrenia?
Not so quick.
Claws and impact
As effectively as placing the research collectively to see the general outcome, the researchers additionally seemed on the high quality of every individual examine. You can charge this on a scale of 0 to 9. For instance, how consultant was the examine of the general inhabitants? How dependable have been the measurements, each of the illness and the publicity (for instance, counting on individuals’s reminiscence of once they had a cat 30 years in the past could be lower than strong). Were there any gaps in who responded? (If everybody within the management group answered the questionnaire however not everybody within the illness group did, you would possibly get a bias in your outcomes). And so on.
The authors discovered eight of the research had a rating of 4 or much less; 9 had a rating above 5. That is, a whole lot of the research have been fairly low-quality, that means that numerous biases and errors may have pushed the outcomes away from actuality – we may, in different phrases, be fooling ourselves by together with these in our total assessment.
In a number of the higher-quality research, corresponding to one from the UK in 2017, no hyperlink was discovered between cat possession and psychosis; one other high-quality examine, from Finland in 2019, discovered solely the tiniest, most borderline relation between cats and psychosis signs.
Looking at a number of the different research that have been rated as high-quality, like one from 2022 in Canada, one doesn’t get the impression that it’s a powerful impact: the hyperlink between cats and schizophrenia was conditional on the person being male, and the cat being a rodent-catcher (very particular associations in research like this – until you are expecting them upfront – are sometimes a sign that you simply’ve bought a statistical fluke slightly than an actual hyperlink).
Looking in additional element on the research undermined my confidence that the cat-schizophrenia hyperlink is actual. And certainly, the authors of the brand new assessment are hardly saying that we now have sturdy proof that cat publicity undoubtedly causes schizophrenia. Instead, they write that “there is a need for more high-quality studies, based on large, representative samples to better understand cat ownership as a candidate risk-modifying factor for mental disorders”.
It’s laborious to disagree. There’s doubtlessly one thing attention-grabbing happening right here, however with out a vary of higher research to actually pin down what’s happening, no one must be overly frightened that their beloved pet could be – actually – driving them mad.
Science hyperlink of the week
As mentioned in this article, let’s not get too excited simply but, however now now we have precise human information that reveals that semaglutide – the chemical that’s in these weight-loss medication you’ve heard a lot about this 12 months – would possibly assist with alcohol and substance use issues, too.
This is Science Fictions with Stuart Ritchie, a subscriber-only e-newsletter from i. If you’d prefer to get this direct to your inbox, each single week, you may join right here.
