If I Die Alone Will My Dog or My Cat Eat Me?

I keep in mind a information report from some time again which claimed {that a} man in his eighties died whereas sitting in a simple chair. After a while household and neighbors started to develop into involved that they hadn’t heard from him and he wasn’t responding to cellphone calls or emails. They requested police to hold out a wellness examine, and after they entered the residence they discovered the person, lifeless. What was most stunning was that in addition they discovered his Labrador retriever mendacity lifeless beside him, apparently a sufferer of hunger. The canine starved to loss of life even if sitting within the chair was a supply of nourishment which might have sustained him — specifically the physique of his proprietor.

article continues after commercial

While the information report couched this as an exquisite instance of affection and loyalty on the a part of the canine, in my extra skeptical scientific thoughts I questioned simply how atypical this habits was, given the truth that dogs (and cats) are carnivores and my expectation would have been that even probably the most loving pet would have tried to remain alive by consuming the physique of their lifeless proprietor.

An Open Question

Recently a good friend of mine alerted me to the actual fact that there have been dialogue streams on Reddit and Quora with individuals musing about whether or not their pet would eat them in the event that they died alone with nobody round to guard their physique. Most of the entries had been anecdotes and opinions. When I checked to see what analysis information was available, I discovered that the scientific literature on this subject was actually fairly scant. Most of the journal articles centered on the forensic science, assessing particular circumstances and making an attempt to find out the character, extent, location, and sequence of chunk wounds, mostly in single case research. I might discover nobody monitoring the frequency or likelihood of pets scavenging their lifeless house owners. I discovered just one research, from a French workforce of investigators headed by Thomas Colard on the University of Lille, which checked out a big sufficient pattern (63 circumstances) to permit reaching some conclusions concerning the normal sample of how a pet may devour their deceased proprietor. However, I might discover nothing concerning the chance that such predation would truly occur.

Historically there are various references to dogs consuming lifeless human our bodies. The Bible refers to Jezebel, spouse of the seventh King of Israel, Ahab, who persecuted the prophet Elijah, and in the end was thrown out of a fortress window and left to be eaten by dogs. Homer makes a number of references to our bodies being eaten by dogs within the Iliad, and a few Islamic communities (in East Africa) think about dogs to be unclean as a result of they consider that they ate the physique of the Prophet Mohammed. However, these cases don’t discuss with pet dogs consuming their house owners, and all of those predations occurred outdoor, quite than in confined indoor areas.

Some Reports From First Responders

In the absence of systematic information, I made a decision to assemble some experiences from three first responders to see if some details about the query might be discovered. All reported observing variations within the habits of pet cats and pet dogs on this state of affairs. One lady who labored for the SPCA and was typically referred to as out to rescue pets when an proprietor died stated, “The dogs guarded their proprietor’s physique even when they’re usually light dogs. They typically had been fairly aggressive when guarding the physique, however they did not eat it. I consider many dogs will starve to loss of life earlier than consuming their proprietor. On the opposite hand the ME [medical examiner] on a number of circumstances instructed me that they noticed proof that the person’s pet cats had been biting or consuming the physique.”

One paramedic instructed me, “We are usually referred to as out when there’s hope that the individual remains to be alive, so we often encounter just lately deceased individuals. In my expertise, it appears like cats will begin chewing on the physique as quickly because it begins to chill. For dogs, it appears to rely upon circumstances, however usually dogs appear to treat the corpse as whether it is nonetheless their proprietor and it appears like they won’t readily eat them — however in fact I do not know what occurs if the physique has been there for a very long time and the canine is ravenous.”

A retired police officer sheds a bit extra mild on the state of affairs. “In my 20 years on the drive I encountered a number of circumstances the place a person had died indoors and solely their pets had been round. Recollecting these, it appears that evidently if the person was newly deceased their dogs would depart them alone, hover close to them, even attempt to shield them. Once the physique had began to putrefy, all bets had been off and I keep in mind a few circumstances the place the canine ate a part of the decomposing physique. I consider that that was as a result of, as soon as decay set in, the scent clues that determine the physique as their proprietor had been gone. On the opposite hand, I appear to recall that not less than in half of the circumstances the place the physique was found inside 48 hours, there was proof that pet cats had been nibbling on the corpse.”

A Possible Trigger for This Behavior

There is a few information offered by the French research I discussed earlier. They discovered that in 24 % of the circumstances when the physique was found inside a day, there was some proof that dogs had consumed not less than some a part of the deceased. However, Markus Rothschild, who was the forensic examiner for one case in Berlin during which a canine consumed a part of its lifeless proprietor, instructed that the canine didn’t initially intend to eat its proprietor however quite, “One possible explanation for such behavior is that a pet will try to help an unconscious owner first by licking or nudging, but when this fails to produce any results the behavior of the animal can become more frantic and in a state of panic, can lead to biting.” If biting results in the canine (or cat) tasting some blood, which may stimulate the intuition to eat.

In the absence of extra stable information I, not less than, have reached the tentative conclusion that if I die and nobody is round for some time my cat can be extra more likely to eat me over the quick run, whereas my canine would wait round some time earlier than consuming me. Personally, if I’m lifeless, I’ve no explicit want for my physique and if it sustains my pets till they’re rescued, that’s tremendous with me.

Copyright SC Psychological Enterprises Ltd. May not be reprinted or reposted with out permission

References