“The Curse,” HGTV and the curb attraction of gentrification

Throughout “The Curse” Asher (Nathan Fielder) and Whitney Siegel (Emma Stone) develop extra determined to be considered good individuals. Wherever Whitney walks within the couple’s adopted New Mexico group of Española, she smiles and waves at strangers, pets their dogs and asks about their spouses. She preaches the feel-good gospel of investing domestically and bringing jobs to this predominately Hispanic and Native American working-class group.

Like the twee strip mall showrooms she and Asher run, they don’t slot in. No matter, since of their view, their mission is to encourage (learn: drive) their neighbors to rise to their requirements.

The couple would vehemently object to that description, insisting that bringing sustainable residing to Española might be a boon to all. Moneyed urbanites trying to find inexpensive housing will flock to the city, Asher hopes, bringing their spending energy, elevating property values and creating new jobs.

What occurs when the cost of residing additionally goes up? In the quick run, and primarily whereas their producer Dougie (Benny Safdie) is filming these good works, Whitney and Asher negotiate on behalf of residents whose rents are going up and forge connections with authorities officers. But they guarantee those that ask that the earnings for the houses they promote might be used to subsidize the locals’ rising rents.

“There are no losers,” they guarantee all doubters, be they longtime residents or a profoundly skeptical TV reporter from an area station.

The newlyweds’ obsessive quest blinds them to their damaging sense of superiority; whilst they imagine they’re doing the best factor they will’t assist screwing over others. A espresso store that includes pour-over brews showcases the couple’s ethos, together with an overpriced denim boutique located subsequent door. This is a component and parcel of Whitney and Asher’s dedication to sustainable residing which they hope to show into an HGTV collection known as “Flipanthropy.” In Española there are many low-priced deserted or tear-down houses in neighborhoods that, to outsiders, have seen higher days.

Asher buys them, and Whitney transforms them into eco-friendly “passive homes” lined in mirrors as if to meld Frank Lloyd Wright’s “organic architecture” philosophy with a disco ball or a carnival funhouse. Inside they’re an Instagram influencer’s fantasy of Southwest stylish with pueblo blankets hanging on whitewashed partitions and earth tone accents.

The present’s title comes from Ash’s fateful interplay with a bit woman promoting soda in a car parking zone, urged into existence by Dougie, who tells him he wants B-roll of Asher doing good deeds.

When it goes sideways, the child inhales deeply, trains a tough glare on Asher, and says, “I curse you.” Those three phrases find yourself holding an influence over him he can’t shake.

Fielder’s forte is cringe comedy honed to a needle’s precision within the cult favorites “Nathan For You” and his recent HBO undertaking “The Rehearsal.” Unlike these improvised sensations “The Curse” is scripted, making its satire extra laser-focused on hitting interlopers like Asher and Whitney – please, name them Ash and Whit! – squarely of their conscience.

But it additionally burst the feel-good consolation we absorb rehab exhibits that play up the the Aristocracy of restoring uncared for properties in “up and coming” neighborhoods. Rarely can we hear concerning the individuals who lived in these locations earlier than or dwell round them now, and infrequently can we take into consideration what life might be like for them as soon as the hosts pack up and the cameras are gone.

Fielder and Safdie co-wrote the collection to be a treatise on gentrification, precise and metaphorical. By inserting it inside the world of home enchancment TV they and co-executive producer Carrie Kemper, who co-wrote two episodes, take away town limits from that idea and current it for what it’s: a wrongdoing normalized by TV, TikTok and Instagram.

Whitney tries to rope within the native artistic group, by courting a supposed buddy who’s each a visible and performing artist, and who barely veils her disdain for Whitney however will fortunately settle for her fawning compliments. (One dependable side of gentrification is the artist’s position as recon agent and shock troops.) Asher merely doesn’t wish to fail and can exploit anybody to make sure he doesn’t, together with former pals and colleagues.

As they try and get “Flipanthropy” up and working Española’s residents hold reminding them of the much less nice realities of attracting newcomers to a place primarily based on photographs projected on TV or on-line. Surely the Gaineses confronted this as they remodeled Waco, Texas, from a place that was infamous for the mistaken causes right into a vacationer vacation spot synonymous with homey Americana. Contemplating the realm’s rising property taxes or longtime residents being priced out and maybe displaced will not be a subject audiences wish to have interaction with. 

Nevertheless in 2019, not lengthy after the Gaineses introduced the launch of Magnolia Network, a reporter from Buzzfeed paid an prolonged go to to Waco to expertise “the Fixer Upper effect” and communicate to the city’s natives about what it’s meant for them.

Depending on who the reporter requested, Chip and Joanna’s town-wide “restoration” has been a Godsend or a blight. The reporter discovered a place that’s, within the shadow of the famed Magnolia silos, welcoming and aesthetically pleasing, and elsewhere has stoked displacement fears on account of skyrocketing property taxes. Additionally, there’s the worry of the existing culture being overpainted in a push for growth that favors shoppers who’re white and higher center class to the detriment of their Black, brown, and Indigenous neighbors.

“They want to come in and fix me. Fix us,” one resident is quoted as saying. But you already know what? We’re not damaged. Do we wish to higher ourselves and our circumstances? Of course. But that doesn’t imply we want fixing.”

This describes the tragicomedy of Asher and Whitney – they’re satisfied they know higher and may subsequently drive individuals to dwell higher. In an upcoming episode, one in every of their new-to-town patrons instantly accuses their neighbors of porch piracy, and Whitney takes it upon herself to police the person, insisting they dwell the “flipanthropy” manner. It doesn’t work as a result of persons are egocentric and do not like being informed what to do – particularly individuals who really feel like their presence is a favor to the communities they’re invading and may in any other case write off if not for the approval of the world’s Whits.

Nathan Fielder as Asher and Emma Stone as Whitney in “The Curse” (John Paul Lopez/A24/Paramount+/Showtime)Some exhibits make a critical effort to do proper by the individuals residing within the locations they’re rehabbing. HGTV’s “Bargain Block” has made stars out of home designers and renovators Keith Bynum and Evan Thomas, who buy a number of tumbledown houses on the identical block in Detroit, repair them up, and promote them for below $200,000.

Their aim is to carry individuals again to city neighborhoods that emptied when town’s economic system tanked and to supply high quality alternatives for first-time homebuyers.  BridgeDetroit says Bynum and Thomas have rehabbed at the very least 40 houses as of June 2023. The hosts additionally work with an area credit score union to help patrons who its president and CEO informed the outlet “haven’t been treated as well by the financial industry and others” to safe mortgage loans.

Want a every day wrap-up of all of the information and commentary Salon has to supply? Subscribe to our morning publication, Crash Course.

The article cites knowledge from native suppose tank  Detroit Future City indicating that white mortgage candidates had been more likely to have their home loans accepted than Black candidates. Nearly 30% of the 1,717 African American home mortgage candidates had been denied in comparison with lower than 15% of the 913 white candidates, the report says.

Of course, as is the case with all of those exhibits, the host and producers of “Bargain Block,” together with their realtor and buddy Shea Hicks-Whitfield, do not know whether or not their homebuyers are from the communities they wish to assist or, like Asher and Whitney’s goal prospects, speculators shopping for right into a neighborhood at a lower cost to promote when the property values rise.

In an actual manner, they seem like making efforts to do good along with that means nicely with an eye fixed on honoring the cultural cloth of the communities the place they’re working, which is a couple of can say about different exhibits selling home rehab as nothing however a web profit for each house owner and neighbors. A blessing, you may say, as an alternative of a curse.

And if not Fielder, Safdie and Stone bringing us the squeamish misadventures of their keen “Flipanthropist” couple in New Mexico, we’d by no means suppose in any other case.

New episodes of “The Curse” premieres Fridays on Paramount+ with Showtime and at 10 p.m. Sundays on Showtime.