Wednesday, February 21, 2024
Wednesday, February 21, 2024
HomePet NewsDog NewsB.C. tribunal settles canine dispute between exes

B.C. tribunal settles canine dispute between exes


Related stories


Tayside canine unit has a brand new four-legged recruit

A brand new Perthshire crime fighter has been appointed. ...
-- Advertisment --
- Advertisement -

When a pair with a canine decides to separate up, who will get custody of their beloved pet?

Break ups can typically result in sophisticated animal custody disputes – as B.C.’s small claims tribunal heard in a current case concerning the possession of a miniature Australian shepherd pet named Mambo.

Whereas Pamela Zwicker took Mambo together with her when she moved out of her ex-boyfriend Daniel MacIntosh’s dwelling again in March, the Civil Decision Tribunal finally dominated that MacIntosh is the rightful proprietor.

Pets are thought-about private property underneath B.C. regulation, which CRT vice-chair Andrea Ritchie acknowledged could make possession tough to find out when private relationships break down.

“Folks are not looking for their pets handled like different private property that may be divided or bought to share the proceeds,” Ritchie wrote in an Oct. 27 resolution.

She referenced MacDonald v. Pearl, a 2017 Nova Scotia case that approached canine possession by way of questions like, “Who bore the burden of the care and luxury of the animal? Who paid for the animal’s maintenance? Who cared for it?”

Zwicker didn’t dispute that MacIntosh bought Mambo and paid for the canine’s veterinary payments, however in a written submission to the tribunal, she rejected the advantage of her ex-partner’s cash, labelling it “household funds.”

In a letter she left MacIntosh after shifting out, Zwicker mentioned she took Mambo due to the pet’s attachment to her personal canine, Harley. She additionally claimed MacIntosh “relinquished possession” two days after the then-couple picked Mambo up from the breeder when he left for an 18-day journey.

Ritchie rejected the notion that MacIntosh’s pre-planned journey, or the journey he’s typically required to do for work, was proof that he ought to surrender Mambo.

“I discover each events love and may adequately help the canine,” Richie mentioned in her resolution, whereas concluding MacIntosh has a “stronger possession declare” over Mambo due to his monetary contributions.

Zwicker has been ordered to return Mambo and the canine’s provides to MacIntosh, in addition to reimburse him for $125 in tribunal charges. CTV Information was unable to succeed in Zwicker in regards to the resolution.

One Fraser Valley household regulation apply recommends {couples} define pet custody agreements to keep away from future disputes of this nature.

“As with different agreements pertaining to the division of property in a relationship…the problem of ‘pet custody’ and the way it’s approached throughout or after the breakdown of a relationship, may be outlined in such agreements,” Dreyer Davison mentioned.

- Advertisement -
Pet News 2Day
Pet News 2Day
About the editor Hey there! I'm proud to be the editor of Pet News 2Day. With a lifetime of experience and a genuine love for animals, I bring a wealth of knowledge and passion to my role. Experience and Expertise Animals have always been a central part of my life. I'm not only the owner of a top-notch dog grooming business in, but I also have a diverse and happy family of my own. We have five adorable dogs, six charming cats, a wise old tortoise, four adorable guinea pigs, two bouncy rabbits, and even a lively flock of chickens. Needless to say, my home is a haven for animal love! Credibility What sets me apart as a credible editor is my hands-on experience and dedication. Through running my grooming business, I've developed a deep understanding of various dog breeds and their needs. I take pride in delivering exceptional grooming services and ensuring each furry client feels comfortable and cared for. Commitment to Animal Welfare But my passion extends beyond my business. Fostering dogs until they find their forever homes is something I'm truly committed to. It's an incredibly rewarding experience, knowing that I'm making a difference in their lives. Additionally, I've volunteered at animal rescue centers across the globe, helping animals in need and gaining a global perspective on animal welfare. Trusted Source I believe that my diverse experiences, from running a successful grooming business to fostering and volunteering, make me a credible editor in the field of pet journalism. I strive to provide accurate and informative content, sharing insights into pet ownership, behavior, and care. My genuine love for animals drives me to be a trusted source for pet-related information, and I'm honored to share my knowledge and passion with readers like you.

Latest Articles



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here
Captcha verification failed!
CAPTCHA user score failed. Please contact us!